Non Gamstop Betting SitesNon Gamstop Betting SitesNon Gamstop Casinos UKBest Casino Not On GamstopBest Non Gamstop Casinos UkUK Non Gamstop Casinos

Scottish Disability Equality Forum����sdef thistle logo

Home

What is SDEF?

SDEF News

Events

Policy

Membership

Contact Us

Links

Policy Papers

DEVELOPING A FORUM/ CONSULTATION MECHANISM SO DISABLED PEOPLE�S VIEWS AND EXPERIENCE CAN INFORM SCOTTISH EXECUTIVE POLICYMAKING

Forum note: this paper was produced by an independent consultant to the Equality Unit.� The Forum seeks your views on the approach set out below, and will feed these into the EYDP steering group.

Sally Witcher, 2 August 2002

Independent Consultant to the Equality Unit

1.��������������� BACKGROUND

The broad idea of establishing some form of �Disability Parliament� or �Consortium� as a means of bringing together the Scottish disability sector in order to inform policymaking by the Scottish executive and others was initially suggested both by Inclusion Scotland and the Scottish Disability Equality Forum during recent (separate) meetings with the Scottish Executive Equality Unit.

Drawing on those discussions, a paper was brought to the first meeting of the EYDP steering group on 11 June. It was felt that the EYDP steering group might be an appropriate place to start as the group was comprised of a range of organisations across the sector and the development of such a mechanism was in keeping with EYDP themes and objectives.

At that meeting it was agreed that it would be a good idea to explore establishing some form of Disability Consortium as part of the EYDP work programme. A revised paper subsequently came to the meeting on 11 July.This paper has been further revised in view of issues and concerns raised on that occasion.

The 11 July meeting agreed that, before progressing the idea further, it was necessary for EYDP Steering Group members to discuss it within their organisations and through their networks, to ensure that this was something that disabled people wanted. That meeting also agreed that it would be appropriate to refer to the proposed mechanism as a �Disability Forum�.

The establishment of effective consultation mechanisms between the SE and the disability sector could have potential to bring benefits to all concerned, helping to improve the quality of policy through opening up access to better information about the barriers confronting disabled people and how they might be overcome. The Equality Unit was keen to stress that it was not its intention to seek to develop any consultation mechanism in a �top-down� way. Instead it hoped to support a �bottom-up� approach � this being the only way to develop effective mechanisms. Disabled people and their organisations clearly know best, not just what they want to say but also what sort of mechanism or structure would best enable their views to be expressed. This was the approach taken to the development of consultation mechanisms with other equality groups. The Equality Unit had supported them to develop consultation mechanisms in way that the equality groups themselves had determined.

The Equality Unit was also keen to stress that the Forum would not replace direct contact between individual organisations and the Executive.Organisations across the disability sector might wish to engage directly with the Executive on particular issues and the Executive would remain open and responsive to all approaches.

This paper is intended to provide a basis for organisations and their networks to discuss:

1.�� If it is important for the views of disabled people and their organisations to be fed into Scottish Executive policymaking, what is the best way to do this?

2.�� What should be the objectives for any form of consultation mechanism?

3.�� What would be the possible dangers to avoid, eg

������ that a �lead� organisation might try to take over

������ that it would diminish the influence of individual organisations

������ that it could become exclusive

������ or just an administrative exercise

4.�� What sort of structure might best meet objectives while avoiding possible dangers?

5.�� How should this be taken forward?

The paper begins by briefly looking at how a Forum/ consultation mechanism could meet both disability sector and Scottish Executive interests. It then sets out suggestions made so far about possible objectives for a consultation mechanism, and perhaps other uses it could serve such as providing a forum for exchange of good practice, strengthening the sector, etc. This also includes objectives designed to guard against possible dangers.The paper then shows how the development of the Forum/ consultation mechanism fits with EYDP and finally sketches out a possible way forward.

2.����� HOW A FORUM/ CONSULTATION MECHANISM COULD MEET DIFFERENT INTERESTS

There seem to be potential advantages for all concerned.

a)����� The disability sector

It is for the sector and those within it to define what their objectives would be with regard to relations with the Scottish Executive. However, it is clear that devolved policy areas have the potential significantly to affect the welfare of disabled people. A structure which facilitates communications and promotes understanding between the sector and the Scottish Executive should therefore be useful from the perspective of all who work to promote the interests of disabled people.

b)����� The Scottish Executive - Equality Strategy

The Equality strategy has three strategic objectives

1.��� making better policy and providing better services � this covers mainstreaming, consultation and research measurement

2.��� promoting equal opportunities and tackling discrimination � covering raising awareness & promoting best practice, communications (external and internal), developing partnerships, representation in public appointments

3.��� being a good employer � targets for representation.

The proposal for a Disability Forum fits very well with most that appears under both the first and the second objectives. Through providing a structure for improving external communications and developing partnerships, input to consultations should be increased across the sector. It should facilitate identification of the full implications of legislation for disabled people, and thus how legislation needs to be framed if their interests are to be mainstreamed.

There is also a role for equality groups to proactively identify policy issues and solutions,This would fit well with the first strategic objective and may be something a Disability Forum could facilitate.

From the first year annual report on the implementation of the Equality Strategy, it is clear that the various equality groups have taken different approaches to setting up structures for communications within their sectors. These may provide a source ideas and guidance on options.

3.����� POSSIBLE OBJECTIVES FOR A �DISABILITY FORUM�

The paper to the meeting of 11 June set out some possible objectives for a Disability Forum. These have been firmed up and amended in view of discussion.

Objectives for work content:

The overall objective would be to provide a framework for civil dialogue, ensuring that disabled people, disability organisations and people with a disability brief working in other organisations can have an input into Scottish Executive policymaking. It might also provide a focus for input to policymaking at UK and European levels.

The Forum�s role or remit would be to bring together key players in the disability sector in order to:

1.��� Promote the mainstreaming of disability issues and interests

2.��� Provide a vehicle for Scottish Executive communications with the sector

3.��� Disseminate information about Scottish Executive consultations to their members/ constituents and act as a conduit for channelling views back to the Scottish Executive

4.��� Provide a forum for allowing all views to be heard

5.��� Where areas of agreement about policy lines or priorities are identified, convey these to the Scottish Executive

6.��� Share information about activities and provide opportunities for learning from each other, eg through the exchange of good practice

7.��� Identify opportunities for partnership working and co-ordination in order to avoid duplication and make best use of resources and different expertise

It could have a reactive role in responding to the Scottish Executive�s policy agenda.

It could have a proactive role in independently identifying priorities, and proposing policy changes

It could have a co-ordinating role in disseminating and exchanging information within the sector

Objectives for ways of working

1.��� The Forum should seek to ensure representation across the sector. It would include members of the Disability Agenda Group, and bring on board others to make it more representative

2.��� Representatives of organisations involved in the Forum would be disabled people wherever possible and they should always be in the majority.

3.��� The Forum should operate in a fair and equitable way, with no one dominating and all members as equal partners

4.��� The Forum should operate in an inclusive, open and collaborative way

5.��� The Forum should avoid being overly rigid and bureaucratic

6.��� The Forum should be independent of the Scottish Executive, although may be supported by it in different ways

7.��� The Forum should allow all views to be aired and should not necessarily seek always to achieve consensus

8.��� While recognising that arguments will be strengthened when diverse players can reach agreement, there needs to be respect for different views, perspectives and expertise.

4.����� RELATIONSHIP TO EYDP

The main theme for the EYDP is �Promoting rights and participation�, with sub-themes of raising awareness, participation and advocacy/ mentoring. The proposed forum clearly fits under �participation�, and may also play a role in increasing awareness. As a forum for promoting the interests of disabled people and for learning from each other, arguably it would also fit with �advocacy and mentoring�.

In the paper to the meeting of 11 June, it was suggested that broad objectives for Scottish EYDP might be:

������� To ensure that there are concrete positive outcomes achieved by the end of the Year

������� To ensure that work undertaken during the Year will continue to bring long-lasting benefits to disabled people in Scotland.

The establishment of a Disability Forum would be consistent with both.

It was agreed at the 11 June Steering Group meeting that the development of a Disability Forum would be an objective for the EYDP. The EYDP Steering Group could provide a starting point for that development. One possibility would be for the Steering Group to evolve into the Forum. Certainly it is hoped that organisations involved in the Steering Group would want to be part of the Forum. The two might run in tandem, or EYDP work might be overseen by a sub-group of the Forum. The latter would have the advantage of locating EYDP work in a wider strategic context while retaining focus. The launch of the Forum could be the focus for the launch of the EYDP, or the Forum might be launched towards the end of the year to signal that the end of the Year does not mean the end of work on disability. Before coming to decisions on this, a number of issues need to be considered before January 2003.

5������ A POSSIBLE WAY FORWARD

1.��� Objectives for the Forum/ consultation mechanism need to be agreed and possible dangers identified, following feedback from consultation

2.��� Models and structures (e.g, Swedish, South African models and those adopted by other equality groups and the Scottish Civic Forum) need to be investigated to see which would best facilitate the achievement of those objectives and avoid possible dangers.

3.��� Objectives and structures need to be set out in the form of terms of reference (like a constitution). These could also cover:

������� Title - what should the Disability Forum be called?

������� Membership � who should be a member of it?

������� Officers � chair/ convenor to rotate, etc

������� Structure � it might want to set up working groups or sub-groups, around particular issues or geographical areas

������� Powers and accountability

������� Frequency of meetings

4.��� Establish a budget and confirmation of ongoing funding from the Scottish Executive

5.��� Identify appropriate (neutral) secretariat?

6.��� Draw up work-plan for the first year


Scottish Disability Equality Forum

Working together for the disability movement

SDEF is a recognised Scottish charity no. SC031893

end of page